- 
maybefbito reconstruct the challenge for verifying an MLSAG signature, i need all key images including the key image for the commitment-to-zero. so am i right in assuming the key image of commitment-to-zero is only ignored when linking two MLSAG signatures in monero?
 - 
sarangMLSAG doesn't use an image for the amount commitment component
 - 
maybefbiyou are right, i checked Z2M2 again and the key images only correspond to one time addresses and their private keys. are we using the private key for commitment-to-zero anywhere? how do we prove to the onlookers i know the difference of blinding factors between the commitment and the pseudo commitment?
 - 
maybefbinever mind i see it now
 - 
maybefbiK_(i,m) is the difference between commitments
 - 
maybefbiwhen m>1
 - 
maybefbibut wait we dont have to know the difference between blinding factors to sign?
 - 
sarangNote that CLSAG does include such an auxiliary key image, but it is not used for linking purposes
 - 
sarangYes you do need to know
 - 
maybefbiwhat for?
 - 
sarangWhat is your question referring to
 - 
maybefbiim trying to combine sections 3.5 and 6.2.2 in Z2M2
 - 
maybefbiim trying to make sense how we are proving to the world that i know the difference between the blinding factors
 - 
gingeropolouswhat ever happened to the university thing with monero research lab, sarang , suraeNoether ? Like one of you was working on an entity or something.
 - 
sarangmaybefbi: you're showing that you know the base-`G` logarithm of the difference between the amount commitment and a commitment offset to the same value
 - 
sarangand then you construct the blinding factors of the offsets and newly-generated amounts to sum to zero
 - 
sarangthis shows balance
 - 
sarangin a signer-ambiguous way
 - 
saranggingeropolous: suraeNoether and others are collaborating with Clemson University to have a student work on a Monero-related project TBD
 - 
gingeropolousyeah but i thought u created a .... thing or something. it was like Magical something.
 - 
sarangsuraeNoether spearheaded a grant organization, MAGIC
 - 
sarangHe has since passed leadership on to others, but you'd have to ask him for details
 - 
gingeropolousbut thats cool too. i was just answering this : old.reddit.com/r/Monero/comments/j0…ow_could/?ref=share&ref_source=link
 - 
gingeropolousah yes, MAGIC, that was it
 - 
maybefbisarang: thanks. let me try writing some code, i will better understand what you said.